Sarah's Cookie Jar

star 5.0 (29 Reviews) •
3508 32 Avenue Northeast, Calgary
Non-Partner Bakery
Free delivery fee, First Order
Delivery: Tomorrow

Sarah's Cookie Jar Menu

Cookies

Bounty Cookie

This cookie is filled and topped with coconut shreds and chocolate, and bounty on top as well! Stuff

$7.80
Campfire Cookie (S'mores)

usually ready in 24 hours A perfectly happy blend of Hershey's chocolate, marshmallows and teddy gra

$7.80
Grinch-ookie

Mint flavored cookie stuffed with Nutella and topped with the Grinch's big heart! Usually ready in

$7.20
Chocolate Chip Cookie

usually ready in 24 hours Everything you want in a cookie, crispy edges, soft middle, and packed wit

$7.80
Cosmic Brookie

usually ready in 24 hours A childhood favourite made into a cookie classic. Fudgy and chewy brownie

$7.80
Pistachio Cranberry

It’s in the name! Perfect blend of with chocolate, cranberries and stuffed with a delicious pistac

$7.20
Peppermint Brookie

Brownie cookie packed with chocolates & topped with white chocolate drizzle and crushed peppermi

$7.20
Dunkaroo Cookie

usually ready in 24 hours This is my childhood wrapped into one special cookie! A graham cookie base

$7.80
Sarah's Cookie Box
Box of 4 $31.20
Ferrero Rocher

usually ready in 24 hours This cookie is packed with chocolate covered hazelnuts, and stuffed with a

$7.80
Kinder Bueno

usually ready in 24 hours

$7.80
Lotus Overload Cookie

usually ready in 24 hours Biscoff stuffed cookie packed with white chocolate chip & topped with

$7.80
Peanut Butter

usually ready in 24 hours Peanut butter dough packed with Reese’s Pieces and topped with a layer o

$7.20
Pistachio Delight

usually ready in 24 hours This cookie is filled with white chocolate, dipped in pistachios, and topp

$7.80
Red Velvet CheeseCake

Usually ready in 24 hours

$7.20
Turtles Cookie

Usually ready in 24 hours Perfect mix of chocolate and vanilla dough packed with chocolate and peca

$7.20
Micro Cookies
$36.00
The SCJ
$7.80
M&M Brookie
$7.80
Dubai Pistachio *Fridays

FRIDAYS ONLY Brown butter vanilla cookie base, stuffed with the viral kanafeh pistachio filling to

$13.20

About Sarah's Cookie Jar

Sarah's Cookie Jar in Calgary | Online Menu + Free Delivery | Customer Reviews

Cookie jars are a huge trend now. Open your Instagram explorer, and you can see them on every major fashion or lifestyle influencer's posts and stories. They are perfect for presents, especially when you're going to someone's home for the first time and need something unique and cute.  Sarah’s Cookie Jar has become one of those gems in Calgary, thanks to its innovative jar design and delicious cookies, ideal for gatherings, quick snacks at work, and many other occasions. 

Sarah’s Cookies Jar has quickly earned a reputation for serving some of the city’s most indulgent, extra-thick, flavor-packed cookies, available in town with a speedy, convenient delivery service from SweetnFresh. 

A Small Cookie Shop With Big Personality on SweetnFresh

What makes Sarah’s Cookie Jar Calgary exceptional is their flavors and the size of their cookies. This is a standout bakery with larger-than-life cookies with flavors that surprise you, feeling modern with a hint of traditional ingredients like M&M, recalling beautiful childhood memories.  You will come in without knowing what to expect and walk out with big boxes of colorful and delicious cookies in cute jars. 

Sarah’s Cookie Jar has also been successful at delivering a warm, cozy vibe with its cookies. One of the main things people mention about this place is its warm atmosphere, where wonderful layered flavors are created, and the iconic thick-baked style cookies. 

A quick look at Sarah’s Cookie Jar reviews shows consistent praise for its creativity, customer service, and impressive portion sizes. Thanks to SweetnFresh, you can get them delivered straight to your door.

Sarah's cookie jar reviews

Flavorful Menu of Sarah’s CooKie Jar in Calgary

Sarah’s Cookie Jar brings magic and charm into every batch. Here are some of the most popular items on the menu now available through SweetnFresh:

  • Campfire Cookie (S’mores): Wonderful gooey mix of chocolate, marshmallow, and graham, bringing back memories of summer nights, perfect for Christmas.

  • Kinder Bueno & Ferrero Rocher: Inspired by the world’s favorite chocolates, each bite is creamy, crunchy, and irresistibly rich, ideal for snacks with afternoon tea.

  • Pistachio Delight: Nutty, aromatic, and perfect for pistachio lovers.

  • Cosmic Brookie & M&M Brookie: A childhood dream, a cookie-brownie hybrid that delivers the best of both worlds.

  • Lotus Overload: Packed with Biscoff flavor, caramel notes, and warm spices.

  • Red Velvet Cheesecake: This one makes a great gift box, a mixture of soft red velvet cookies filled with creamy cheesecake.

  • Micro Cookies: You can order them for parties or as a shareable option for office treats.

Each cookie is thick, soft, and generously loaded with fillings and toppings, ideal for photos, too. If you love browsing Sarah’s Cookie Jar photos, you already know how irresistible they look, perfect for aesthetic and even advertising photography to make a cool and cozy vibe. 

Why Does Calgary Love Ordering From Sarah’s Cookie Jar?

If you are a fan of cookies and always need something sweet and delightful on your counter, it's time to stop searching “cookies near me Calgary” and check out SweetnFresh Sarah’s Cookie Jar. With every order, you’ll understand why locals quietly include it in their personal lists of the best bakeries Calgary has to offer.

Whether you’re searching for a local hidden gem, exploring new sweets in the area, or typing “cookies near me Calgary” hoping for something extra special, Sarah’s Cookie Jar is the treat you’ve been looking for. SweetnFresh makes it even easier, just pick your favorites, place your order, and enjoy Calgary’s most decadent cookies delivered warm, soft, and unforgettable.

Sarah's Cookie Jar Reviews

B
Brianna H ★★★★
Nice little surprise walking into Cedar’s deli and finding these amazing cookies!! The flavours were absolutely incredible and Sarah is just the sweetest! All flavours were awesome, but the mini egg Nutella stuffed was definitely a favourite!!
F
Fatina Hattum ★★★★
Me and the kids Decided to try out these cookies, let me tell you we are forever hooked!!! The best cookies we have ever had! Customer service was great, very kind and helpful. Did I mention the cookies are huge!! We definitely will be ordering again.
M
Monique Charest ★★★★
First of all, the customer service is a 10/10. Sarah is lovely to deal with. There was a miscommunication (on my part) and she totally went above and beyond to fix it which was super nice. The COOKIES (I ordered 8 flavours) are amazing! 12/10. The flavours are spot on and they taste like they are made with love. I live just outside of Calgary and we have a “fancy” cookie shop in my town… When I tell you the 40 min drive each way for Sarah’s Cookies is beyond worth it… I MEAN IT. I don’t have enough good things to say about this place.
E
Ermenita Duraku ★★★★
The best cookies ever!!! Sarah is professional and really welcoming. The best customer service as well. I highly recommend you visit Sarahs bakery!
P
Paulina Westergard ★★★★
Meeting Sarah was a treat as she is as lovely as her delicious cookies! We will back to try every flavour